Evictions in Indiana: What Every Merrillville Landlord Should Know

If you’re a landlord in Merrillville, Indiana, you probably didn’t get into real estate for the courtroom drama. But sometimes, the script flips. Rent goes unpaid. Rules get broken. And suddenly, you’re googling “How do I evict a tenant in Indiana?” faster than your tenant ghosted your texts.

Evictions aren’t fun. They’re not fast either. But if you know the process and follow it by the book, you’ll keep your sanity (and your rental income) intact. Let’s break it all down, minus the legal mumbo jumbo and boring lawyer-speak.

Eviction in Indiana: The Quick (But Not-So-Sweet) Overview

Indiana’s eviction laws give landlords the right to evict tenants who don’t pay rent, break lease terms, damage the property, or do things like illegal activity. Fair enough, right? But you can’t just toss their stuff to the curb like it’s a sitcom. There’s a whole legal path you’ve got to walk, and it starts with…

1. The Notice: Start With a Nudge (the Legal Kind)

Before you even think about filing an eviction case, you’ve got to serve notice. There are a few flavors of this, depending on what went wrong:

10-Day notice to pay or quit: If the tenant missed rent, this gives them 10 days to pay up or pack up.
Notice for lease violation: If they’ve been throwing wild parties, sneaking in pets, or turning your unit into a TikTok studio, you can give them a notice (with a chance to fix it).
Unconditional quit notice: For serious stuff, like illegal activity, you can ask them to leave without a second chance.

Important: Always serve notices in writing. And no, Post-Its on the door don't count.

2. File an Eviction Lawsuit: Hello, Small Claims Court

If your tenant ignores the notice or refuses to fix the issue, it’s time to file an eviction case. In Merrillville, you’ll head to Lake County Small Claims Court. Filing fees range from $86 to $126, depending on the number of tenants and whether you want to recover damages.

You’ll get a hearing date, usually within 20 days, and the tenant will be served a court summons.

3. The Hearing: Where Landlords and Tenants Tell Their Sides

Think of this like the Judge Judy part. You’ll need to bring receipts. Literally. Documentation is your best friend: the lease agreement, payment records, photos of damage, text messages…all of it.

The judge will decide whether to grant the eviction and whether your tenant owes you money.

If you win, the court gives the tenant a few days to move out voluntarily. If they don’t…

4. The Sheriff Gets Involved

No, you can’t change the locks yourself. No, you can’t toss their furniture onto the lawn in the middle of the night. In Indiana, only the sheriff can carry out the physical eviction, typically 7-14 days after the ruling. Make sure you’re ready with movers and a locksmith on standby.

Some Numbers to Keep in Mind

In 2022, Indiana landlords filed over 48,000 eviction cases.
Lake County alone accounted for nearly 4,000 of them.
The average cost of an eviction (including lost rent, legal fees, and turnover costs) is over $3,500.
A single missed rent payment in Merrillville (where the average rent is about $1,100/month) can easily set you back weeks in income.

Moral of the story? Prevent when you can. Prepare when you can’t.

Tips to Dodge the Eviction Drama Altogether

Eviction should always be Plan Z. These tips can help you avoid getting there in the first place:

Screen like a pro: Credit checks, income verification, rental history, don’t skip this step.
Clear lease terms: Confusion leads to conflict. Be crystal clear on rules, rent, and what happens if things go south.
Communicate early: If rent’s late, reach out right away. Sometimes a simple convo beats court.
Use tech: Online rent portals make payment easier and leave a digital trail (aka proof).

Wait, What About Squatters?

If someone’s living in your property without permission and they’re not on the lease, it gets tricky. Indiana law doesn't give them much protection if they’ve never paid rent, but you still need to follow legal steps. Call the police first. If that doesn’t work, it may turn into an eviction case.

Landlord, Meet Lifesaver: C.A.P.S.

All this legal wrangling making your head spin? You’re not alone. That’s where C.A.P.S. Property Management comes in. We know Indiana landlord-tenant law like the back of our lease binder. Whether it’s helping with notices, coordinating with attorneys, or just keeping tenant relationships smooth, we take the mess out of managing rentals.

Even better? We handle rent collection, tenant screening, maintenance, and all those "not my favorite part of the job" tasks so you can focus on the ROI, not the WTFs.

You don’t have to face evictions alone. C.A.P.S. has your back, before, during, and after the court date.

Final Thought Before You (Legally) Kick 'Em Out

Eviction isn’t revenge. It’s business. And like all business decisions, it should be smart, strategic, and legal. Stay cool, follow the rules, and lean on pros like us at C.A.P.S. when you need a helping hand, or a firm handshake from the sheriff.

Because when the rent stops flowing, the right steps will keep your rental biz from tanking.